Book Entry · Science Fiction

Downward to the Earth

by Robert Silverberg · 1970

More Silverberg → Reviews on SFcrowsnest

What is Downward to the Earth about?

Edmund Gundersen returns to Belzagor, the jungle world he once helped administer, eight years after Earth relinquished it to its two native species — the elephantine nildoror and the fierce sulidoror — carrying a colonial administrator's guilt and a tourist visa. His pilgrimage upcountry to the mist sites, where the nildoror undergo their sacramental rebirth, becomes an application to undergo it himself: atonement by transfiguration. Silverberg's Conrad homage (a character is named Kurtz, lest anyone miss it) turns Heart of Darkness inside out — the horror upriver is replaced by something the coloniser must beg to join.

Why it matters

Widely rated among the finest SF novels about colonialism; its sacramental aliens and penitent imperialist predate (and arguably outclass) several famous successors, Avatar included.

Read next

The Dispossessed

Ursula K. Le Guin · 1974

Hugo, Nebula and Locus winner; the standard against which all political SF is measured, taught in politics departments as readily as literature ones.

The Fifth Head of Cerberus

Gene Wolfe · 1972

Wolfe's first masterpiece and the standard demonstration text for unreliable narration in SF; its post-colonial hall of mirrors anticipated discussions the field took decades to catch up with.

Foreigner

C. J. Cherryh · 1994

The launch of SF's longest-running first-contact study (twenty-plus volumes and counting) and the genre's most sustained meditation on translation as survival.